Comparison of Drag-Sled and Skidding-Vehicle Drag Factors on Dry Roadways 2006-01-1398
Lightweight “drag sleds” have long been used by crash investigators to determine the “drag factor” at a crash scene. Despite this long history, no published work has ever shown a correlation between drag sled results and the skidding performance of vehicles on multiple “uncalibrated” surfaces. Indeed, some researchers have noted that their testing appeared to show a poor correlation between the two. It has become clear in recent years that the interaction between braking or skidding tires and pavement does not fit the simple weight- and speed-independent friction model that has been assumed, leaving the accuracy of drag sleds in doubt. This paper presents the results of several comparison tests at different locations, involving multiple skid-test vehicles, dozens of drag sleds of various designs, and more than a hundred “pullers,” and attempts to correlate the results of the two methods. Drag sleds tended to read higher than even the peak value generated with skidding cars, though occasionally this was not the case, and no relationship between individual drag sled results and skidding vehicle results could be identified which applied across multiple surfaces.
Citation: Bartlett, W., Baxter, A., Livesay, E., Schmidt, B. et al., "Comparison of Drag-Sled and Skidding-Vehicle Drag Factors on Dry Roadways," SAE Technical Paper 2006-01-1398, 2006, https://doi.org/10.4271/2006-01-1398. Download Citation
Author(s):
Wade Bartlett, Albert Baxter, Ed Livesay, Bruno Schmidt, Terry Stanard, William Wright
Affiliated:
Mechanical Forensics Engineering Services, LLC, Suncoast Collision Analysis, Ed Livesay & Associates, Missouri State University, Human Effectiveness Directorate, Wright Patterson AFB, Florida Atlantic University
Pages: 28
Event:
SAE 2006 World Congress & Exhibition
ISSN:
0148-7191
e-ISSN:
2688-3627
Also in:
Accident Reconstruction 2006-SP-1999, SAE 2006 Transactions Journal of Passenger Cars: Mechanical Systems-V115-6
Related Topics:
Drag
Historical reference
Technical review
SAE MOBILUS
Subscribers can view annotate, and download all of SAE's content.
Learn More »